How to Measure Success as a Surface Pattern Designer When Sales Are Slow

You check Spoonflower and see two sample sales this month. Your Etsy shop has been quiet for weeks. Your inbox has zero licensing inquiries. You’ve been painting, posting and showing up on socials, but nothing seems to be moving and you can’t see when that will change. Somewhere in there a quiet thought creeps in: maybe I’m not cut out for this.

I remember that season. When I opened my Etsy shop in 2021, I measured everything by sales. Slow week, slow month and I felt like I was failing.

What I couldn’t see was everything growing underneath. Most of my licensing opportunities have come through DMs. My sales numbers never would have told me that was coming, but every pattern I created and shared was building toward it.

Sales matter. They just aren’t the only way to measure growth, especially early on. Here’s what to look at instead.

1. Write down the wins that come before the money

Most income shows up after months of quiet progress. Finishing a hero print, a brand following you back, someone saving your pattern on Pinterest. Every one counts and builds momentum toward the opportunities you’re hoping for.

2. Measure what you can control

You can’t control who buys or when a brand reaches out. You can control how often you create and share. Instead of “get a licensing deal this month,” try “share my work three times this week and paint new artwork for a mini collection.” Those goals you can actually reach, and they’re the ones that lead to the deals.

3. Look back months, not days

One slow week tells you very little. Set a pattern from last November beside one from this month. Look at your color, your composition, your confidence. That growth is real, even before anyone pays for it.

4. Count the people

A lasting creative business is built on relationships. The artist who always comments on your posts. The brand that replied “not right now,” which is a door left open. The community where you share your newest collection for feedback. Each of them is part of your story and will present opportunities in the future.

Your next step

Set aside 20 minutes with a notebook and answer three questions:
What can I do now that I couldn’t do a year ago?
What is one win I didn’t stop to celebrate?
What is one thing I can control this month that moves me toward my goal?

Then write down three wins from this past month, big or small.

If you want a community to celebrate those wins with, The Creative Mentorship is a place where 350+ artists share their work, get feedback and cheer each other on every day.

Explore The Creative Mentorship